Best Cigar Shops & Lounges in Brookhaven, NY

Best Cigar Shops & Lounges in Brookhaven, NY

Whether you’re a seasoned connoisseur seeking a plush lounge with the perfect pour or a casual stogie aficionado who just wants a relaxing spot to puff with friends, I got you covered. Overall, there are many great options for cigars in Brookhaven. Our top choice for best spot for cigars in Brookhaven is Island Wood Cigars & Smoke, but there are many to choose from.
Our list covers the top cigar havens in Brookhaven, NY, catering to all walks of the cigar world. Fancy a place with top-shelf drinks and leather armchairs? We have it. Craving a chill hangout with a no-nonsense vibe? You bet. Looking to stock up on your favorite smokes, by the stick or the box? Yep, got that too. So, light up a metaphorical pre-amble cigar, settle in, and let’s explore the best cigar experiences Brookhaven has to offer!

Top 3 Cigars Spots in Brookhaven

1. Island Wood Cigars & Smoke, 5/5
2. Long Island Cigar, 5/5
3. Big Daddy Cigars, 5/5

Guide to Choosing a Cigar Lounge & Shop in Brookhaven, NY

Choosing the right cigar spot in Brookhaven isn’t just about the sticks, folks. There are many factors to consider for that perfect cigar sanctuary. First off, let’s talk budget. Are you rolling in dough, ready to drop some serious cash on fancy drinks and premium lounge memberships? Or you more of a kick-back-and-relax smoker on a budget?
What about selection? If you’re just looking for common cigars then most places will be ok, but if you’re looking for limited edition cigars or boutique brands, know that not every spot will have what you’re looking for.
Next up, lockers. If you’re a regular, having a personal humidor at the lounge is clutch – no more hauling your sticks around!
Then there’s the booze situation. Do they have a full bar with your favorite whiskeys, or are you stuck with a limited selection? Bonus points if you’re allowed to bring your own and not pay an opening or corking fee.
Finally, consider the vibe. Some spots get crazy crowded, while others have a mellow, laid-back feel.
Picking the right spot means matching your preferences and taking all these factors into account.

10 Best Cigars Lounges and Shops in Brookhaven

1. Island Wood Cigars & Smoke

Rating: 5/5
Phone: (631) 650-5900
Address: 181 E Main St East Islip, NY 11730 United States
About: Specialities we are the only one around offering the freshest cigars with the widest selection.

2. Long Island Cigar

Rating: 5/5
Phone: (631) 750-6800
Address: 4775 Sunrise Hwy North Service Rd Bohemia, NY 11716 United States
About: Specialities Long Island Cigar is the largest cigar lounge on Long Island. We’re known for our premium cigars and great lounge environment. We also offer cigar packages for cater to weddings, family events, meetings, team-building events, and more. Contact us today or come on by our lounge in Bohemia.

3. Big Daddy Cigars

Rating: 5/5
Phone: (631) 468-8222
Address: 343 Smithtown Blvd Ronkonkoma, NY 11779 United States
About: Specialities We are a full service cigar shop and lounge. You come in and get greeted and welcomed by staff who’s goal is not to sell you bu earn your business. History Established in 1990. We have continued to offer a wide selection and a place to sit and smoke. Meet the Business Owner Business owner information Chris R. Business Owner Chris has been in the cigar business for over 20 years with hands on knowledge of each and every cigar.

4. Matador Cigars – Hauppauge

Rating: 5/5
Phone: (631) 656-8228
Address: 582 Veterans Memorial Hwy Hauppauge, NY 11788 United States
About: Specialities COVID-19 Update: Back to normal hours. Mask required in the store unless you are seated. Matador Cigars is Long Island’s premier tobacconist. Offering wide selection of premium cigars, as well as an elegant and comfortable atmosphere to enjoy them. History Established in 2008. Our first location opened in 2008 in Roslyn Heights. We opened our second location in Massapequa Park in September 2014. We most recently opened our third location in Hauppauge on March 7th 2016. Meet the Business Owner Business owner information Boris G. Business Owner Boris’ passion for cigars are unmatched. Walk into any one of the three Matador Cigar locations and its evident. Only the best premium cigars available, in the cleanest most comfortable lounges this side of the city.

5. South Shore Cigar Club

Rating: 5/5
Phone: (631) 623-5265
Address: 344 N Windsor Ave Brightwaters, NY 11718 United States
About: South Shore Cigar Club is your source for cigars in Brookhaven. Visit South Shore Cigar Club’s website for more information about hours and selection.

6. Smoke Therapy

Rating: 5/5
Phone: (631) 619-6058
Address: 215 Ronkonkoma Ave Ronkonkoma, NY 11779 United States
About: Specialities comfortable cigar lounge with a great selection of cigars fantastic clientele and the best way to escape a stressful day

7. Goodfellas Cigars

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (631) 714-5900
Address: 2215 Rt 112 Medford, NY 11763 United States
About: Specialities Walk in humidor and sit down lounge. Non Members lounge is open to anyone that purchases any cigar. Private lounge available to members only Monthly cigar events Cigar rollers for special occassions History Established in 2007. Goodfellas Tobacco opened in July of 2007 and very quickly became a really nice friendly place to hang out, smoke a cigar and meet great people. We have monthly events to introduce different manufactures and offer cigar specials. We also offer private membership.

8. Village Cigar Headquarters

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (631) 307-9033
Address: 185 Waverly Ave Patchogue, NY 11772 United States
About: Specialities ~Top Selection of Premium Cigars ~Luxurious Cigar Lighters, Cutters, Ashtrays & Accessories ~Personalized & Custom Engraved Wood Humidors ~Customized Cigar Labels ~Cigar Rolling Packages ~Unique Tobacciana & Antique Collectibles ~Cigar Gift Sets & Gift Cards Available History Established in 2013. Village Cigar Headquarters is a specialty shop nestled in the Village of Patchogue. We are the home of the world’s finest premium cigars, pipes and luxurious tobacco accessories. Our elegant & classy establishment is full of unique products you will not find anywhere else. We invite both men and women, smoker or non smoker to come down and experience a mystical and unique journey upon entering “The Cigar Museum”. As a family business, we have over 25 years experience in the tobacco & retail industry. Whether our Tobacco Specialists are educating our guests on certain cigars or planning a cigar rolling event, Our main goal is to provide everyone of our guests exceptional service. Come on down and see what everyone is talking about…. It’s the new home of the Cigar & Pipe Aficionado. Meet the Business Owner Business owner information Josephine B. Business Owner A leader in the Tobacco Industry with 25 years of retail cigar shop experience.

9. Cigar Cigars

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (631) 750-9000
Address: 203 Railroad Ave Sayville, NY 11782 United States
About: Specialities Come on down and enjoy a cigar from our huge selection of Name Brands and House Blends at unbeatable prices on Long Island. Whether you are on the go or want to sit down. You are welcomed to enjoy watching your favorite team on our Big Screen TVS. We Carry A Wide Variety Of Premium Dominican, Nicaraguan And Honduran Cigars Accesories, Humidors and Much More. This Lounge Is Unique Like No Other. It Has A Home Away From Home Feel. Plus the owner is renowned cigar roller Junior. History Established in 2006. In 2006 Cigar Cigars Lounge Was Born. Cigar Cigars Is Located On The South Shore Of Long Island In The Heart Of Sayville On Railroad Ave. Between the LIRR And Main Street Meet the Business Owner Business owner information Junior R. Business Owner I Started Working At A Cigar Factory in the Dominican Republic Operated And Ran By My Family for Over 25 Years. My passion For Cigars Began Over 17 Years Ago. I learned About The Tobacco Industry As A Young Adult. I Literally Started “From The Ground Up” Sweeping The Warehouse Floors, Fermenting The Tobacco, Packaging 100 Pound Sacks Of Tobacco, Packaging & Labeling Cigars And Finally Learning How To Make Cigars By Hand. I Am Very knowledgeable, Great Host and Friendly. I Am A Cigar Roller With “First Hand” Knowledge.

10. Taj Crown of India

Rating: 4.4/5
Phone: (631) 323-6507
Address: 10 Woods Corner Rd East Setauket, NY 11733 United States
About: Specialities Serving the richness of authentic Indian cuisines.

Basic Cigar Lounge Etiquette

Alright, so you’re ready to venture into a cigar lounge and be a respectable member of the smoky community. Here’s a quick rundown of some essential cigar lounge etiquette tips:
Cut and toast your own cigar. Most lounges provide tools, but don’t expect staff to do this for you. It’s part of the ritual!
Ask before lighting up next to someone. You might love the smell, but always be courteous to others.
Dispose of ashes and bands properly. Use the ashtrays, and keep the lounge clean.
Respect the cigars. Don’t handle other people’s smokes without permission, and avoid putting your mouth directly on someone else’s stick.
Mind your smoke. Try to direct smoke away from others. A breezy day calls for extra careful puffing!
Keep the noise down. Lounges are meant for relaxation and conversation, so try not to disrupt the vibe.
Tip the staff. Just like at a bar, tipping your servers is a sign of appreciation and good etiquette.
Don’t be afraid to ask questions. If you’re new to the scene, don’t hesitate! Most lounge regulars are happy to offer guidance.
Remember, a good cigar lounge is about enjoying your smokes in a welcoming and respectful environment.

View more New York cigar shops here: