Best Cigar Shops & Lounges in Ithaca, NY

Whether you’re a seasoned connoisseur seeking a plush lounge with the perfect pour or a casual stogie aficionado who just wants a relaxing spot to puff with friends, I got you covered. Overall, there are many great options for cigars in Ithaca. Our top choice for best spot for cigars in Ithaca is TisMart Cigar Shop, but there are many to choose from.
Our list covers the top cigar havens in Ithaca, NY, catering to all walks of the cigar world. Fancy a place with top-shelf drinks and leather armchairs? We have it. Craving a chill hangout with a no-nonsense vibe? You bet. Looking to stock up on your favorite smokes, by the stick or the box? Yep, got that too. So, light up a metaphorical pre-amble cigar, settle in, and let’s explore the best cigar experiences Ithaca has to offer!

Top 3 Cigars Spots in Ithaca

1. TisMart Cigar Shop, 5/5
2. AT Walley, 4.5/5
3. Al’s Wine & Whiskey Lounge, 4/5

Guide to Choosing a Cigar Lounge & Shop in Ithaca, NY

Choosing the right cigar spot in Ithaca isn’t just about the sticks, folks. There are many factors to consider for that perfect cigar sanctuary. First off, let’s talk budget. Are you rolling in dough, ready to drop some serious cash on fancy drinks and premium lounge memberships? Or you more of a kick-back-and-relax smoker on a budget?
What about selection? If you’re just looking for common cigars then most places will be ok, but if you’re looking for limited edition cigars or boutique brands, know that not every spot will have what you’re looking for.
Next up, lockers. If you’re a regular, having a personal humidor at the lounge is clutch – no more hauling your sticks around!
Then there’s the booze situation. Do they have a full bar with your favorite whiskeys, or are you stuck with a limited selection? Bonus points if you’re allowed to bring your own and not pay an opening or corking fee.
Finally, consider the vibe. Some spots get crazy crowded, while others have a mellow, laid-back feel.
Picking the right spot means matching your preferences and taking all these factors into account.

10 Best Cigars Lounges and Shops in Ithaca

1. TisMart Cigar Shop

Rating: 5/5
Phone: (315) 622-8889
Address: 628 S Main St North Syracuse, NY 13212 United States
Website: tismartcigarshop.com
About: TisMart Cigar Shop is your source for cigars in Ithaca. Visit TisMart Cigar Shop’s website for more information about hours and selection.

2. AT Walley

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (315) 282-7314
Address: 119 Genesee St Auburn, NY 13021 United States
Website: atwalley.com
About: Specialities Specialty Cocktails Fine Wines Relaxing Upscale atmosphere History Established in 2013. A.T. Walley & Co. has been established by a local management group with combined food and beverage experience of over 75 years. Our goal at Walley’s is to revolutionize the local cocktail sceneA.T. Walley & Co. offers a very unique venue that includes its decor, cocktail selections, and premium wines, which are all housed in a vintage 225 year old building. You will be treated to professional service, awesome food, fine cigars and an eclectic array of music. AT Walley also recommends Balloons Restaurant & Catering 68 New American, Italian AT Walley says, “Fine Dining Before or After Cocktails” The Counter 3 Ice Cream & Frozen Yoghurt, Delis, Sandwiches AT Walley says, “Great spot in Downtown Auburn. Just a few blocks away. Full Deli with specialty burgers, dogs, fries, and ice cream.Breakfast, lunch, and dinner.”

3. Al’s Wine & Whiskey Lounge

Rating: 4/5
Phone: (315) 703-4773
Address: 321 S Clinton St Syracuse, NY 13202 United States
Website: alswineandwhiskey.com
About: Al’s Wine & Whiskey Lounge is your source for cigars in Ithaca. Visit Al’s Wine & Whiskey Lounge’s website for more information about hours and selection.

4. SX Hookah Lounge

Rating: 4/5
Phone: (315) 214-4903
Address: 1441 Milton Ave Syracuse, NY 13209 United States
Website: sxhookah.com
About: Specialities Customize your own personal hookah with a fruit head, adding a flavor base or an iced hose. We also have hookah products, vapors, and cigars for sale. With over 10 televisions and a projector, you can relax and watch all sporting events, UFC fights, and the latest music videos. Check our upcoming events or call us for more information.

5. Central Ave Cigar Club

Rating: 4/5
Phone:
Address: 518 1/2 N Central Ave Minoa, NY 13116 United States
Website: syracusecigarclub.com
About: History Established in 2000. We are a private cigar lounge for Syracuse area cigar enthusiasts. Amenities include 24/7 access to our clubhouse/smoking rooms, a cigar locker in our humidor room, invitations to exclusive cigar events, access to our card room & pitch leagues, and lifelong friendships. For more information, tours/visits or interested in a membership application, please email CentralAveCigarClubLtd@gmail.com.

6. Abel’s Pub

Rating: 4/5
Phone:
Address: 65 Rotary Ave Binghamton, NY 13905 United States
Website:
About: Specialities Friendly atmosphere, with cold low priced beer and cocktails. Enjoy some popcorn, pretzels and city chicken with some friends in an old neighborhood pub. History Established in 2010. Abel’s Pub opened on November 9, 2010 in the previous location of the Pine Lounge which graced these grounds from 1968 until 2008. The Pub was named after the first mayor of Binghamton, Abel Bennett. Abel owned much of the land adjacent to Abel’s Pub which he eventually subdivided in small farm plots which now make up the westside of Binghamton. Abel is credited for inventing the coal elevator and for starting several businesses and banks in the 1860’s and 70’s in Binghamton. However is biggest influence on this business was the introduction of trolley cars to the westside of Binghamton, which led to the development of the streets and neighborhoods from which many of our customers reside. Meet the Business Owner Business owner information Marty S. Business Owner Binghamton born and raised, youngest of 7 kids. Graduate of Binghamton High School, Saint Bonaventure University and Binghamton University. In the bar/restaurant business since 1988. Married since 1991, with 3 kids.

7. Rocky’s Cigars

Rating: 4/5
Phone: (315) 422-1997
Address: 447 N Salina St Syracuse, NY 13203 United States
Website: rockyscigars.com
About: Specialities We are the #1 Cigar Store in Upstate, NY open over 30 years, with a huge selection and inventory featuring famous brands, boutique makers and hard to finds. We carry Montecristo, Acid by Drew Estate, Liga Privada, Ashton,Arturo Fuente, Fuente Opus X, Rocky Patel, Tatuaje and hundreds more brands, sizes and shapes.. Enjoy your cigars in our cigar lounge. Check out over 40 Craft Beer Selections at the LOWEST Prices. History Established in 1985. Rocky’s is a local store that specializes in Premium Cigars, Lottery, and Micro-brews. We are known as the store that NEVER closes. Meet the Business Owner Business owner information Mike G. Business Owner I’ve been running Rocky’s for over 30 years taking it from a neighborhood store to a destination store for anyone in CNY looking for the best selection of FRESH premium Cigars.

8. NIce Ash Cigars

Rating: 3.5/5
Phone: (585) 364-3773
Address: 36 Jefferson Ave Fairport, NY 14450 United States
Website: niceashnews.com
About: NIce Ash Cigars is your source for cigars in Ithaca. Visit NIce Ash Cigars’s website for more information about hours and selection.

9. Chili’s

Rating: 3/5
Phone: (607) 272-5004
Address: 608 S Meadow St Ithaca, NY 14850 United States
Website: chilis.com
About: Chili’s is your source for cigars in Ithaca. Visit Chili’s’s website for more information about hours and selection.

10. Smokers Choice

Rating: 2.5/5
Phone: (585) 905-3028
Address: 63 Eastern Blvd Canandaigua, NY 14424 United States
Website: smokerschoiceusa.com
About: Specialities HaHa Hookahs was designed to bring you the highest grade tobacco and top of the line pipes coupled with a fun and relaxing atmosphere. Gorgeous marble tables and comfortable leather couches surrounded by flat-screen televisions fill the lounge area. Located inside of Smokers Choice, it is truly a place you can come to chill with friends and meet other tobacco enthusiasts.

Basic Cigar Lounge Etiquette

Alright, so you’re ready to venture into a cigar lounge and be a respectable member of the smoky community. Here’s a quick rundown of some essential cigar lounge etiquette tips:
Cut and toast your own cigar. Most lounges provide tools, but don’t expect staff to do this for you. It’s part of the ritual!
Ask before lighting up next to someone. You might love the smell, but always be courteous to others.
Dispose of ashes and bands properly. Use the ashtrays, and keep the lounge clean.
Respect the cigars. Don’t handle other people’s smokes without permission, and avoid putting your mouth directly on someone else’s stick.
Mind your smoke. Try to direct smoke away from others. A breezy day calls for extra careful puffing!
Keep the noise down. Lounges are meant for relaxation and conversation, so try not to disrupt the vibe.
Tip the staff. Just like at a bar, tipping your servers is a sign of appreciation and good etiquette.
Don’t be afraid to ask questions. If you’re new to the scene, don’t hesitate! Most lounge regulars are happy to offer guidance.
Remember, a good cigar lounge is about enjoying your smokes in a welcoming and respectful environment.

View more New York cigar shops here: https://scotchcigars.com/cigar-shops-lounges/new-york/