Best Cigar Shops & Lounges in New Castle, NY

Best Cigar Shops & Lounges in New Castle, NY

Whether you’re a seasoned connoisseur seeking a plush lounge with the perfect pour or a casual stogie aficionado who just wants a relaxing spot to puff with friends, I got you covered. Overall, there are many great options for cigars in New Castle. Our top choice for best spot for cigars in New Castle is Il Primo Amore, but there are many to choose from.
Our list covers the top cigar havens in New Castle, NY, catering to all walks of the cigar world. Fancy a place with top-shelf drinks and leather armchairs? We have it. Craving a chill hangout with a no-nonsense vibe? You bet. Looking to stock up on your favorite smokes, by the stick or the box? Yep, got that too. So, light up a metaphorical pre-amble cigar, settle in, and let’s explore the best cigar experiences New Castle has to offer!

Top 3 Cigars Spots in New Castle

1. Il Primo Amore, 5/5
2. 1015 Convenience and Tobacco, 5/5
3. Brothers Fish & Chips, 4.5/5

Guide to Choosing a Cigar Lounge & Shop in New Castle, NY

Choosing the right cigar spot in New Castle isn’t just about the sticks, folks. There are many factors to consider for that perfect cigar sanctuary. First off, let’s talk budget. Are you rolling in dough, ready to drop some serious cash on fancy drinks and premium lounge memberships? Or you more of a kick-back-and-relax smoker on a budget?
What about selection? If you’re just looking for common cigars then most places will be ok, but if you’re looking for limited edition cigars or boutique brands, know that not every spot will have what you’re looking for.
Next up, lockers. If you’re a regular, having a personal humidor at the lounge is clutch – no more hauling your sticks around!
Then there’s the booze situation. Do they have a full bar with your favorite whiskeys, or are you stuck with a limited selection? Bonus points if you’re allowed to bring your own and not pay an opening or corking fee.
Finally, consider the vibe. Some spots get crazy crowded, while others have a mellow, laid-back feel.
Picking the right spot means matching your preferences and taking all these factors into account.

10 Best Cigars Lounges and Shops in New Castle

1. Il Primo Amore

Rating: 5/5
Address: 3651 Hill Blvd Jefferson Valley, NY 10535 United States
About: Il Primo Amore is your source for cigars in New Castle. Visit Il Primo Amore’s website for more information about hours and selection.

2. 1015 Convenience and Tobacco

Rating: 5/5
Phone: (914) 739-6113
Address: 1015 Park St Peekskill, NY 10566 United States
About: Specialities Specializing in Premium and Boutique Brand Cigars Also carry Tobacco and Tobacco Related Products, Vape and E-Cigarettes. History Established in 2019. Currently renovating and adding Cigar Lounge and Private Membership. Meet the Business Owner Business owner information Camilo Q. Business Owner Camilo is here to serve the needs of the Cigar Aficionado and those interested the Cigar Lifestyle!

3. Brothers Fish & Chips

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (914) 488-5141
Address: 172 N Highland Ossining, NY 10562 United States
About: Specialitiesfish and chips .seafood creative cuisine tasting menuHistoryEstablished in 2011.My brothers and I have been serving fresh fish and chips at our location in Ossining. We pride ourselves on cooking delicious food made to order, with only the freshest quality ingredients. In 2016 we opened our first restaurant and bar next door to outtake location. came enjoy our fish and chips dinner or try one of our house specialties-either way, we have a feeling you are going to love As the saying does: Restautant and take out serve different menu same chef EAT FISH. LIVE LONGER.

4. The Cigar Republic

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (914) 592-1580
Address: 133 East Main St Fl 2 Elmsford, NY 10523 United States
About: Specialities Largest Boutique Cigar Selection and the Best Prices in New York. The Cigar Republic prides itself on selling only the finest cigars from around the world at competitive prices. Personalized customer service and knowledgeable staff can assist you in purchasing the perfect smoke. In addition to carrying familiar and popular brands, The Cigar Republic features several private labels and boutique, home grown labels. History Established in 1996. The Cigar Republic is a family-owned and operated premium cigar retail shop and private lounge. As third generation Tobacconists, the Scipioni brothers opened their first shop in 1996. Having humble beginnings in Elmsford, NY, we have now opened our second location in Danbury, CT! From the knowledge and experiences of being in the cigar industry for seventeen years, we look forward to serving Danbury and the surrounding areas.

5. Casa Hispaniola Fine Tobacconist of Nyack NY.

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (845) 358-9300
Address: 140 Main St Nyack, NY 10960 United States
About: Specialities Cigar Store of Nyack Ny. Cigar Lounge, Pipe Tobacco, Corporate Events, Cigar Rolling Events, Cigar Wholesale, Bachelor party. History Established in 1992. The Announcement of Casa Hispaniola Fine Tobacconist Cigar Lounge of Nyack NY.. With our rich history and reputation, Casa Hispaniola opened it’s second flagship in the USA and took over the oldest cigar humidor in Nyack NY. It has grown into one of the leading cigar boutique that allows us to fulfill our mission to provide the highest quality products across all our cigar brands connoisseurs have come to enjoy the consistency. Meet the Business Owner Business owner information Melo H. Business Owner For over four generations the Melo and Matos families have been one of the largest producers of the finest organic coffee and aged tobacco in the Dominican Republic, focusing in exportation of coffee as well as supplying some of the largest fine cigar distributors and importers in the Dominican Republic with aged cured tobacco. In 2002 following the ambitious entrepreneurial drive and knowledge of both coffee and tobacco growing, Hugo F. Melo, a fourth generation tobacco and coffee master blender decided it was the right time to venture into the cigar export market launching the Hispaniola Brand, and Introducing it to a very selective market segment. The launch served as a springboard for other cigars within the distinctive Hispaniola portfolio. Casa Hispaniola Fine Tobacconist of Nyack NY. also recommends Casa Hispaniola 5 Tobacconists Melo H. says, “the greatest cigar Atmosphere.”

6. Pour

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (914) 864-0606
Address: 241 E Main St Mount Kisco, NY 10549 United States
About: Specialities Pour is a boutique bar + eatery. Housed in an early 19th Century Victorian house on Main Street in Mt. Kisco, Pour focuses on flavors and labels you may not have heard of before, have wanted to try, or can’t find anywhere else. A well-executed menu of small plates, flatbreads, paninis, charcuterie + cheeses promises to please, while a thorough wine, brew + booze menu offers options for everyone. Specializing in Boutique Wines , Small Production Spirits, Craft Beers, Artisanal Cheeses & Charcuterie. Pour…Westchester’s Best Kept Secret. History Established in 2007. Pour has become the go to place for boutique wines, craft beers & rare whiskeys in Westchester. With it’s low key atmosphere and laid back vibe, Pour is the alternative to everyone else. No blaring music, no TV’s, no bright lights. So whether you’re looking for a great spot to take a first date, meet up with some friends or just chill on your own, stop by and see why Pour has been voted Best of Westchester every year since opening. Meet the Business Owner Business owner information Anthony C. Business Owner Working at a Los Angeles liquor store while pursuing a career in music, Anthony was bit by the wine bug. Accustomed to living like a typical musician: late nights, cheap beers and Ramen noodles, his eyes were opened to the wonderful world of wine by a bottle of 97 Jordan Cabernet. His palate has never been the same. Fast forward to 2006 and living back in NY, he set out to open a wine bar reminiscent to the ones he visited on a trip to Rome and Barcelona with his son. He knew it had to be small and quaint with excellent wines and delectable small plates. In October 2007 Pour was born. 5 years later and 8 “Best of Westchester” awards as well as “The Slow Food Snail of Approval” Pour continues to delight.

7. Doc James Cigars

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (914) 962-9388
Address: 952 E Main St Shrub Oak, NY 10588 United States
About: Specialities Westchester’s Premiere Fine Cigar Shop for over 20 years. Fantastic selection of name brands and boutique blends. Internet pricing on box purchases. Members only 1300 sq ft state of the art smoking lounge complete with 4 tv’s, wifi, cigar lockers and more. Official Tommy Bahama men’s apparel and accessories. History Established in 1993. Doc James dating back to the 1960’s was a part time pipe and tobacco shop. In 1993 Adam DeSiena bought it, opened it full time and geared the business more towards premium cigars. The cigar boom hit in 1996 and Doc James has never looked back. The business has grown over the years and is now housed in a 2,000 square foot space. 2013 will be the launch of the DeSiena 312 cigar exclusively manufactured by Doc James, which will be distributed nationally. Meet the Business Owner Business owner information Adam D. Business Owner Adam bought and transformed Doc James in 1993, 20 years later the store has grown and he now is delving into the manufacturing side of the premium cigar market. In 2004 Adam expanded his business to include his passion of golf. Now Doc James Cigars & Golf includes Tommy Bahama, Callaway and Nike golf products.

8. Captain Lawrence Brewing

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (914) 741-2337
Address: 444 Saw Mill River Rd Elmsford, NY 10523 United States
About: Captain Lawrence Brewing is your source for cigars in New Castle. Visit Captain Lawrence Brewing’s website for more information about hours and selection.

9. The peoples cigar republic

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (914) 418-5272
Address: 33A Nepperhan Ave Elmsford, NY 10523 United States
About: The peoples cigar republic is your source for cigars in New Castle. Visit The peoples cigar republic’s website for more information about hours and selection.

10. The Hudson House

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (845) 353-1355
Address: 134 Main St Nyack, NY 10960 United States
About: The Hudson House is your source for cigars in New Castle. Visit The Hudson House’s website for more information about hours and selection.

Basic Cigar Lounge Etiquette

Alright, so you’re ready to venture into a cigar lounge and be a respectable member of the smoky community. Here’s a quick rundown of some essential cigar lounge etiquette tips:
Cut and toast your own cigar. Most lounges provide tools, but don’t expect staff to do this for you. It’s part of the ritual!
Ask before lighting up next to someone. You might love the smell, but always be courteous to others.
Dispose of ashes and bands properly. Use the ashtrays, and keep the lounge clean.
Respect the cigars. Don’t handle other people’s smokes without permission, and avoid putting your mouth directly on someone else’s stick.
Mind your smoke. Try to direct smoke away from others. A breezy day calls for extra careful puffing!
Keep the noise down. Lounges are meant for relaxation and conversation, so try not to disrupt the vibe.
Tip the staff. Just like at a bar, tipping your servers is a sign of appreciation and good etiquette.
Don’t be afraid to ask questions. If you’re new to the scene, don’t hesitate! Most lounge regulars are happy to offer guidance.
Remember, a good cigar lounge is about enjoying your smokes in a welcoming and respectful environment.

View more New York cigar shops here: