Best Cigar Shops & Lounges in Rye, NY

Best Cigar Shops & Lounges in Rye, NY

Whether you’re a seasoned connoisseur seeking a plush lounge with the perfect pour or a casual stogie aficionado who just wants a relaxing spot to puff with friends, I got you covered. Overall, there are many great options for cigars in Rye. Our top choice for best spot for cigars in Rye is Smoke and Mirrors Cigar Lounge, but there are many to choose from.
Our list covers the top cigar havens in Rye, NY, catering to all walks of the cigar world. Fancy a place with top-shelf drinks and leather armchairs? We have it. Craving a chill hangout with a no-nonsense vibe? You bet. Looking to stock up on your favorite smokes, by the stick or the box? Yep, got that too. So, light up a metaphorical pre-amble cigar, settle in, and let’s explore the best cigar experiences Rye has to offer!

Top 3 Cigars Spots in Rye

1. Smoke and Mirrors Cigar Lounge, 5/5
2. Doc James Cigar Lounge, 4.5/5
3. Tobacconist of Greenwich Ltd, 4.5/5

Guide to Choosing a Cigar Lounge & Shop in Rye, NY

Choosing the right cigar spot in Rye isn’t just about the sticks, folks. There are many factors to consider for that perfect cigar sanctuary. First off, let’s talk budget. Are you rolling in dough, ready to drop some serious cash on fancy drinks and premium lounge memberships? Or you more of a kick-back-and-relax smoker on a budget?
What about selection? If you’re just looking for common cigars then most places will be ok, but if you’re looking for limited edition cigars or boutique brands, know that not every spot will have what you’re looking for.
Next up, lockers. If you’re a regular, having a personal humidor at the lounge is clutch – no more hauling your sticks around!
Then there’s the booze situation. Do they have a full bar with your favorite whiskeys, or are you stuck with a limited selection? Bonus points if you’re allowed to bring your own and not pay an opening or corking fee.
Finally, consider the vibe. Some spots get crazy crowded, while others have a mellow, laid-back feel.
Picking the right spot means matching your preferences and taking all these factors into account.

10 Best Cigars Lounges and Shops in Rye

1. Smoke and Mirrors Cigar Lounge

Rating: 5/5
Phone: (914) 630-0239
Address: 614 Fenimore Rd Ste 2307 Mamaroneck, NY 10543 United States
Website: smoke-mirrors-cigar-lounge.bus…
About: Specialities Our lounge is cozy and comfortable. We focus on our patrons and understand the need to enjoy a fine cigar. We offer amenities such as coffee, espresso, latte, cappuccino, soda, water and ice for a beverage of your choice. We do not sell alcohol. We understand the need to feel relaxed and we try our best to create the ultimate cigar experience.

2. Doc James Cigar Lounge

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (914) 630-7333
Address: 133 E Prospect Ave Mamaroneck, NY 10543 United States
About: Specialities As one of only 200 Davidoff Merchants in the US, the Doc James Cigar Lounge provides the full experience that you’re looking for when you want to smoke fine cigars and have a good time, with good company! Housed in a former horse barn that has been remodeled while still keeping the charm, we have a comfortable and relaxing setting to sit down and enjoy our products. Serviced by a friendly and knowledgable staff, Doc James only provides the finest products to our customers in order to ensure that you have the best experience you’re looking for when you come in our doors! History Established in 1938. Doc James started in 1938 selling custom blended tobacco. It has evolved into two full service premium cigar lounges. Meet the Business Owner Business owner information Joshua D. Business Owner Been in the service business for 20yrs & cigar business for 9yrs. Here at Doc James we have created a cigar lounge that just breeds relaxation and enjoyment. From the selection of fine cigars to our friendly & knowledgeable staff. A must try for any cigar smoker.

3. Tobacconist of Greenwich Ltd

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (203) 869-5401
Address: 8 Havemeyer Pl Greenwich, CT 06830 United States
About: Specialities Davidoff, Padron, Arturo Fuente, The Griffin’s, Avo, Opus X, God of Fire, Ashton, La Aroma De Cuba, Casa Magna, Zino Platinum. We custom blend all of our pipe tobacco by hand. We sell an array of luxurious smoking accessories, including humidors, ashtrays, ST Dupont Lighters, Lotus Lighters, Porsche Design Lighters, and Pipes. We offer a smoking lounge to members of our club and in certain instances, walk in traffic. We have 2 cigar events annually where cigars, wine, spirits, luxurious watches, exquisite food and high end sports cars are all part of the price of admission. History Established in 1974. The Tobacconist of Greenwich, LTD was established in 1974 by the legendary Jimmy “Cigars” Lacerra. We have established our own stamp within the cigar industry and have been a staple in Greenwich for 48 years. We pride ourselves in providing our customers the best quality tobacco products available. Our expertise and knowledge of cigars, pipes and smoking accessories will surly gain the confidence of our customers. We have a loyal following of customers, some who have been patronizing The Tobacconist since in inception. Many of our customers have become life long friends. Meet the Business Owner Business owner information Michael C. Business Owner Please come in and visit our store.

4. Hatuey Cigars

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (914) 315-6888
Address: 164 E Boston Post Rd Mamaroneck, NY 10543 United States
About: Specialities The Hatuey Cigars are genuine of our family. Our ancestors began manufacturing “This Habano” in Cuba, which is enjoyed today in many parts of the world. Our cigar factory, Tabacalera Hatuey, is located in Dominican Republic, in the Cibao valley, which is one of the most prestigious locations known worldwide to grow tobacco. We have established our tobacco crops in many areas of the Cibao, such as, Bonao, Villa Gonzalez, Navarrete, Piloto, Cotui, as well as others, from where we obtain fine and aromatics leaves used in our blends. Our company is dedicated to continue the tradition and culture began in Cuba. The Hatuey cigar repeatedly uses the same tobacco seeds in the diferents varieties, as well as the same curing process to conserve years and years of consistency and quality of this fine Dominican cigar. We have our tobacco processing center, where we store, classify, ferment and age all tobaccos produced in our crops… History Established in 1932. We are a Cuban family with three generations of experience growing and curing tobacco. Years ago we put forth our family honor in order to make a new premium cigar totally hand rolled by our family in the Dominican Republic. Our cigars use all Cuban seed tobacco grown and cured in the old Cuban tradition. More than 2500 companies sell cigars in the United States and of that only 2% grow and cure their own tobacco as well as manufacture their own cigars. We are included in that small percentage and is at the top of its class. Hatuey Cigars is committed to bringing you the quality and consistency of a fine cigar. Are you ready for this great experience? Meet the Manager Business owner information Hector A. Manager Hector is very attentive to his customers and also very knowledgeable about the cigar world. He makes everyone feel at home when you visit the store. He always takes care of his customers!!

5. Doc James Cigar Lounge

Rating: 4.5/5
Phone: (914) 630-7333
Address: 133 E Prospect Ave Mamaroneck, NY 10543 United States
About: Doc James Cigar Lounge is your source for cigars in Rye. Visit Doc James Cigar Lounge’s website for more information about hours and selection.

6. Benjamin Steakhouse

Rating: 4/5
Phone: (914) 428-6868
Address: 610 Hartsdale Rd White Plains, NY 10607 United States
About: Specialities Winner of “Best Steakhouse and Best Rib Eye” from Westchester Magazine, Benjamin Steakhouse is the ultimate dining experience! Benjamin Steakhouse offers an extensive menu that is sure to please. For steak lovers, Chef McLeod prepares juicy cuts of steak, from 36-ounce Porterhouses to juicy, tender Ribeyes and succulent filet mignon- all dry-aged in their very own aging box, which holds up to 25,000-30,000 lbs of beef. Those with a more aquatic taste may feast on rich and buttery Chilean Sea Bass, or the extravagant seafood platter, including fresh oysters on the half shell, jumbo shrimp, half-lobsters and juicy lump crabmeat. Chef McLeod also whips up flavorful new takes to steak-house classics, such as lightly-breaded crab cakes, sizzling Canadian bacon, and his signature “Creamless” Creamed Spinach. History Established in 2010. After more than 35 years in the steakhouse business, executive chef Arturo McLeod partnered with fellow Peter Luger alumnus Benjamin Prelvukaj to create Benjamin Steakhouse. Since the opening of their Manhattan location in 2006, they have enjoyed culinary acclaim in outlets such as the Zagat and Michelin food guides and have been featured in The New York Times, Gotham, W Magazine and more. Now with its second location, opened four years to the date of its original, Benjamin Steakhouse has expanded to the heart of Westchester County. The White Plain’s version brings with it the familiar décor of the Manhattan location, with its signature dark wood floors, banquette seating, burgundy booths, and chocolate leather chairs in tow. The new location also features an oversized fireplace, located in the center of the Main Dining Room, as well as the opportunity to dine outdoors or in the spacious bar and lounge area. Meet the Business Owner Business owner information Benjamin P. Business Owner Benjamin Prelvukaj is the ambitious young entrepreneur that founded Benjamin Steak House. Benjamin, along with Chef Arturo McLeod, started Benjamin Steak House in 2006. Since then, Benjamin Steak House has established itself as one of New York’s premiere steak houses, attracting business professionals and celebrities alike. Now, with a new location right in White Plains, Benjamin Steakhouse brings all its glory right to the heart of Westchester County. Benjamin Steakhouse also recommends Benjamin Steakhouse 1476 Steakhouses, Seafood, Bars Benjamin P. says, “Benjamin Steakhouse has established itself as one of New York City’s premier steakhouses, attracting business professionals & celebrities alike.” Sea Fire Grill 1556 Seafood, Steakhouses, Bars Benjamin P. says, “The Sea Fire Grill offers locally-sourced, contemporary American seafood where consistency in execution and highlighting the fish itself is priority.” Benjamin Steakhouse Prime 513 Seafood, Steakhouses, Bars Benjamin P. says, “Benjamin Restaurant Group is highlighting the grill at Prime, serving up USDA prime dry aged steaks and succulent seafood in unique ways.”

7. Bangkok City

Rating: 4/5
Phone: (914) 738-7070
Address: 100 5th Ave Pelham, NY 10803 United States
About: Specialities Thai Restaurant in Pelham, NY.

8. Rye House

Rating: 4/5
Address: 126 N Main St Port Chester, NY 10573 United States
About: Specialities Rye House Port Chester, an American craft bistro and bar, specializes in a globally influenced approach to American cuisine with an expansive offering of American small batch whiskies, spirits, craft beer and wine within a casual, yet elegant setting. The Rye House menu, helmed by Executive Chef Anne McKinney, brings together a wide array of dishes across various cultures, all of which have become American comfort staples. A curated beverage program, featuring a selection of American small batch whiskies, craft beers and wines, complement the elevated American cuisine. The large spirits list features hundreds of Rye, Bourbon, and Scotch whiskies, in addition to tequilas, mezcals, rums and vodkas which are highlighted in a progressive cocktail menu developed in conjunction with the Rye House NYC beverage team. A dozen American craft beers are on tap and will rotate weekly, and wines, all offered by the bottle and glass, highlight top American wineries from the Finger Lakes, Columbia Valley and Napa Valley. History Established in 2014. Due to its prime location right off the Metro-North Railroad and its close proximity to The Capitol Theatre and the AMC Loews & IMAX Movie Theatre, Rye House Port Chester is a welcomed destination for New York City commuters, Westchester residents and New York City residents looking to take a quick trip outside the city. We hope to see you soon!

9. Yard House

Rating: 3.7/5
Phone: (914) 375-9273
Address: 237 Market St Yonkers, NY 10710 United States
About: Specialities Yard House, the modern American gathering place where beer and food lovers unite, is an upscale, casual eatery known for great food, classic rock music, an energetic vibe and endless fleet of tap handles featuring the best American craft and import beers. Each Yard House location offers 100+ draft brews along with an array of craft cocktails. Beer is our passion, which means we’re always staying on top of the latest and greatest brews from around the corner and around the world. At any given moment, we have 3,000 gallons of beer flowing through our keg room to 100+ taps at our center-island bar. We also have a rotating Chalkboard Series featuring unique and complex beers from local, domestic and import brewers. Our globally inspired menu features more than 100 made-from-scratch favorites, from signature starters like Poke Nachos and Fried Mac + Cheese, to street tacos, grilled burgers, pizza, seafood and steak. Each Yard House has a distinct vibe with original artwork, a hand-picked playlist of 10,000 classic songs, and glass-enclosed keg room housing up to 3,000 gallons of fresh, quality beer. Founded in Long Beach, Calif., in 1996, Yard House now spans across the U.S. with over 75 locations and is open daily for lunch, dinner, happy hour and late-night dining. History Established in 1996. When the craft beer revolution started 21 years ago, Yard House had a vision – to create the largest draft beer system in the world. We took our experience with brews and breweries and coupled it with a kitchen that creates culinary innovations to be enjoyed in an energetic atmosphere.The restaurant’s name was derived from an early Colonial tradition of serving 36-inch tall glasses – or yards – to weary stagecoach drivers. The age-old custom was a popular tradition in the early days of Yard House as guests drank beer from the signature three-foot glass vessel. Today, guests can sip their favorites from the half yard, pint glass, 23-ounce nonic glass and beer samplers.Equal to our passion for what’s trending in beer is our interest in what’s cropping up on today’s innovative menus. Executive Chef Carlito Jocson is always developing new ways to fuse globally inspired flavors with favorite American dishes, giving our menu a worldly yet familiar feel.

10. Ava Ava Restaurant Bar & Lounge

Rating: 3.5/5
Phone: (914) 235-2070
Address: 15 Division St New Rochelle, NY 10801 United States
About: Specialities Ava Ava Bar & Grill is a Latin Fusion, Caribbean restuarant with an eye-opening experience and great ambiance.

Basic Cigar Lounge Etiquette

Alright, so you’re ready to venture into a cigar lounge and be a respectable member of the smoky community. Here’s a quick rundown of some essential cigar lounge etiquette tips:
Cut and toast your own cigar. Most lounges provide tools, but don’t expect staff to do this for you. It’s part of the ritual!
Ask before lighting up next to someone. You might love the smell, but always be courteous to others.
Dispose of ashes and bands properly. Use the ashtrays, and keep the lounge clean.
Respect the cigars. Don’t handle other people’s smokes without permission, and avoid putting your mouth directly on someone else’s stick.
Mind your smoke. Try to direct smoke away from others. A breezy day calls for extra careful puffing!
Keep the noise down. Lounges are meant for relaxation and conversation, so try not to disrupt the vibe.
Tip the staff. Just like at a bar, tipping your servers is a sign of appreciation and good etiquette.
Don’t be afraid to ask questions. If you’re new to the scene, don’t hesitate! Most lounge regulars are happy to offer guidance.
Remember, a good cigar lounge is about enjoying your smokes in a welcoming and respectful environment.

Check all New York cigar shops here.