A Nicaraguan binder and an all-Dominican long-filler mix are encased in an oily, leathery, dark, reddish-brown Ecuadorian Habano leaf for the H. Upmann 1844 Reserve Churchill cigar. The Dominican Republic’s Tabacalera de Garcia expertly handcrafts this superb, medium-bodied cigarette.

The flavor profile of this cigar was composed of earthy, creamy, sweet, and somewhat spiciness notes. A flawless draw and clean burn are provided by its structure. Its construction ensures a perfect draw and clear burn.

Wrapper Origin: EcuadorianShape: Churchill
Length: 7Ring: 50
Wrapper: HabanoList Price: $225.75 (Box of 25)
Origin: Dominican RepublicStrength: Medium

Appearance of H. Upmann 1844 Reserve Churchill

The H. Upmann 1844 Reserve Churchill cigar is firmly packed, very well made and has super nice appearance. It has a rustic appearance, but not too awful. The cigar has a double cap, the color is very dark brownish type of wrapper with a few minor veins.

This cigar’s band is positioned at the customary spot practically next to the cap, which is the band position for almost all cigars. The words H. Upmann and “1844” are printed in white letters on a red backdrop in the center of the band. The word “Reserve” is likewise written, however it is positioned below and is in the color black. A backdrop of copper and gold frames every feature.

Smoking Experience

My initial impression after lighting the H. Upmann 1844 Reserve Churchill cigar is how excellent yet slightly constrained the draw is. In addition to having a very smooth mouthfeel and retro-hale, it imparts a taste that is both woody and earthy. Furthermore, it gives a very rich, oily, and smooth tobacco flavor. The finishes are blended woody and earthy flavors with a hint of creaminess, sweetness, and dryness. The tastes linger in the mouth for quite a while, notably the richness and creaminess. A nice cigar thus far.

After my first third, the ash is hanging out pretty good. Medium pepper is present in the retro-hale, along with tastes of wood and earth. The finishes are the same as before, with notes of wood, earth, cream, sweetness, and this time a hint of spice. This cigar’s body is medium, and it produces a lot of smoke. Also, it’s been burning well with no touch-ups from me. The tastes are now strong, consistently pleasant, and truly a smooth-aged tobacco.

For the second third, I have no problem when it comes to its burn. The flavors are practically comparable, and the cigar’s creaminess and sweetness with a hint of leather really show through at the draw. As the cigar’s finish develops, I can also start to taste the aged tobacco. It still produced excellent smoke, and the draw is easing slightly, but I don’t think this is an issue.

The cigar still has a peppery flavor on the retro-hale during the last third. The draw still has leather and wood notes, and the finishes are earthy and woody as well. There is absolutely no change in flavor; all notes remain the same as they were in the first three thirds. Spice and pepper are already at their optimum. The creaminess and sweetness are still at the same level. Even if the tastes don’t alter throughout, the cigar is still wonderful. In terms of flavor-blend, the cigar is quite constant and the body is still medium at the finish.


Since the brand in general is highly constant when it comes to the flavor combination of the entire line they produce, I had previously expected the H. Upmann 1844 Reserve Churchill to be a very consistent cigar with no flavor variations at all between thirds. You shouldn’t anticipate a significant change in flavor with this one if you’re expecting one. However, it is not dissatisfying because it offers a really creamy and smooth experience. It has a medium body and delivers the same same tastes throughout.

The cigar performs admirably and has a lovely structure. A really impressive performance is given off by the smoke production and burn. If you’re looking for a cigar with a medium body and wonderful flavors like wood, earthy, creamy, sweet, and spicy that are constant throughout its thirds, this one could be for you.

Other Cigars Reviews

Other H. Upmann Cigar Reviews

H. Upmann Connoisseur

H. Upmann Connoisseur cigars are a testament to the great Cuban legacy of the brand. It comes with a chocolate vintage wrapper that hails from Connecticut. It also uses binder and filler tobaccos from the Dominican Republic. Every piece of the Connoisseur gives you a smooth and medium-bodied smoke as well as lush mellow flavors that are composed of cocoa, chocolate, caramel, sweet spice, and caramel that are mouthwatering.

H. Upmann Sun Grown Magnum

The H. Upmann Sun Grown Magnum provides a consistent and robust smoking experience, demonstrating why H. Upmann remains a revered brand in the cigar industry. Underneath its eye-catching red-and-yellow band and oily dark brown Ecuadorian Sun Grown wrapper, this cigar combines Nicaraguan and Honduran long-filler tobaccos bound by a Connecticut Broadleaf. The pre-light aroma tantalizes with sweet baking spices, honeysuckle, cocoa, and cedar, leading into a flavor profile that offers notes of chocolate, woody sweetness, fruitiness, cedar, leather, and sweet spice, with a backdrop of creaminess and a lingering spicy finish. Though it encountered a few burn issues and required several relights towards the end, turning the smoke a bit harsh and bitter, this review of H. Upmann Sun Grown Magnum delivered an enjoyable and flavor-rich smoking session, earning an 85-point rating. With the potential to improve with aging, it promises to be a worthwhile addition to any humidor, appealing to seasoned and novice palates with its straightforward and luscious flavors.

Other Dominican Cigar Reviews

Camacho American Barrel Aged Robusto

The Camacho American Barrel Aged Robusto is a unique and patriotic cigar that combines the traditional taste of Camacho cigars with the rich flavors of American bourbon. The Corojo filler tobacco is aged for five months in bourbon barrels, resulting in a complex and full-bodied smoking experience. With notes of vanilla, cayenne, cedar, and cocoa, this cigar offers a well-rounded and enjoyable flavor profile that is sure to please any cigar enthusiast. The construction of the cigar is excellent, with an even burn and good smoke output. Overall, this review of Camacho American Barrel Aged Robusto highlights it as a must-try cigar for anyone looking for a rich and flavorful smoking experience.

Arturo Fuente Especiales

The Arturo Fuente Especiales Cazadores offers a budget-friendly option for cigar enthusiasts seeking high-quality cigars at an affordable price. With its Ecuadorian Habano wrapper and medium strength, the cigar provides a smooth and creamy smoking experience with woody, cedary, and sweet notes complemented by a touch of pepper. While the construction and burn of the cigar were satisfactory, some inconsistency in the flavor profile was noted, with occasional coffee and cocoa notes and a weakening of the pepper as the cigar progressed. Overall, the Arturo Fuente Especiales Cazadores is a decent, middle-of-the-road option for those seeking a creamy and smooth smoke at a reasonable price, as highlighted in this review of Arturo Fuente Especiales.

For more information about the best cigars and other ways to relax make sure to come back to Scotch & Cigars here.

Maria Morales

Maria Morales