Best Mellow Cigars

Just as an artist feels a connection towards his artwork, so does a smoker to his dearest cigar. The strokes of each shape correspond to the core of the tobacco, the splash of paint to the canvass is the harmonious sound coming from the cigar cutter, the aesthetically pleasing color blend equates to the fascinating blaze of a lit cigar, and, most importantly, the final work of art is the feeling of smoking the fine cigar.
Regardless of the price, it is of great importance to consider the comfort of your palate. Some might opt for intricately mixed medium cigars, whereas many are more likely to engage in smoking full blast cigars bearing a mindset that it makes them ‘genuine’ smokers. However, we must not forget how a mellow cigar could bring such ease and joy whenever they are around. They provide warmth during our mornings and even accompany us to parties and golf sessions, but the big question is, which cigar would you allow in those precious moments of yours?
With that being said, it is our honor and pleasure to help you find a great company with our top picks of mellow-bodied cigars. We ought to fulfill why you’re here — to find what you like.

Top 10 Mellow Cigars

Table of Contents

#1 Macanudo Café Hyde Park

#1 Best Mellow Cigar

The ubiquity of Macanudo tells us that they are too remarkable to be ignored. Its well-known name embodies a trifecta: terrific quality, unparalleled greatness, and stupendous crafts. As an icon of progress, Macanudo Café Hyde Park is every aficionado’s first love, including our own enthuiast Glyn, thanks to its blissfully subtle smoke that makes everyone’s taste buds elated. The seamless and breathtaking golden-brown Connecticut wrapper, enveloping the sweet-scented blend of Dominican and Mexican tobaccos, exudes a delectable smoky flavor with aromas of vanilla, bread, and sweet spice — a great company to pair with a cup of freshly brewed coffee on a cold morning.
Macanudo Café Hyde Park is not solely excellent for being mellow-bodied; it also comes #9 in our best picks of Dominican cigars. Therefore, we can guarantee that there is no room for error here.
5.50 × 49
Wrapper type: Connecticut
Length: 5.50
Ring: 49
Shape: Parejo
Binder: Mexico
Filler: Dominican Republic / Mexico
Origin: Dominican Republic
Strength: Mellow
Wrapper Shade: Natural

#2 Acid Blue Kuba Kuba

#2 Best Mellow Cigar

Drew Estate modus operandi is simple: indisputable and versatile craftsmanship; that is well incorporated in its Acid cigars. Bearing an indescribable taste, the four unique cigar lines to choose from are: Acid Blue, Acid Purple, Acid Gold, and Acid Red. An interesting attribute of these cigars is that they do not share the same mixture. However, what impressed the meticulous palate of our connoisseur, Maria is the Acid Blue Kuba Kuba, so we highly recommend this for you to enjoy. Right after it hits your tongue, expect an unconventional flavor fusion from this infused cigar. The inviting aromas of honey, cocoa, lemon zest, burgundy, and white pepper create a rich mouthfeel that coats the palate with ecstasy. The key to their secret blend is still a mystery—burns close to perfection; every smoke is always an exploration.
5 × 54
Wrapper type: Ecuador Sumatra
Length: 5
Ring: 54
Shape: Parejo
Binder: Nicaragua
Filler: Nicaragua
Origin: Nicaragua
Strength: Mellow
Wrapper Shade: EMS

#3 Ashton Classic Churchill

#3 Best Mellow Cigar

Ashton Classic Churchill is a crowd’s favorite, so it is no surprise that our cigar expert Maria Morales, loves to smoke it regularly. She makes sure to withdraw this cigar from her humidor after a rejuvenating slumber because why not? Consistently on top of its game, this captivating tobacco has inadvertently become the standard of mellow-bodied cigars uncompromising quality and blend. The carefully matured Dominican core denotes a flawless construction, conveying an aromatic, nutty, and creamy taste on the cold draw. Upon firing up, brace yourself with these perfectly balanced dainty flavors: sliced almonds, woody cedar, cashews, honey, and pepper. Available in a cedar chest of 25, you’d be a willing captive to its enticingly delicate smoke.
7.50 x 52
Wrapper type: Connecticut Shade
Length: 7.50
Ring: 52
Shape: Parejo
Binder: Dominican Republic
Filler: Dominican Republic
Origin: Dominican Republic
Strength: Mellow
Wrapper Shade: Natural

#4 Baccarat Rothschild

The classic golden band of Baccarat shows that they are one of the earliest cigar brands to withstand the test of time, with a history dating back to 1871. Renowned for its sweet blend, Baccarat ‘The Game’ Rothschild is a perfect pick from the top-shelf selection of Davidoff, which is intriguingly rolled by hand in the popular Camacho factory. The pleasing subtlety of its sweetened cap gives off a nice and soothing feeling to the taste buds. When lit, a creamy texture that goes along with woody cedar will gently kiss your palate, while the faint touch of pepper around the edges will tingle your nose in the retrohale. For five dollars, you’ll get more than what you deserve; the price is low, but hey, this naturally stylish stick is a great way to start your morning.
5 × 50
Wrapper type: Connecticut Shade
Length: 5
Ring: 50
Shape: Parejo
Binder: Mexico
Filler: Honduras
Origin: Honduras
Strength: Mellow
Wrapper Shade: EMS

#5 Oliva Connecticut Reserve Toro

#5 Best Mellow Cigar

Everyone is in awe of how the crucial process of growing and aging tobaccos are executed flawlessly by Oliva Cigar Co., further creating blends that are far from ordinary. Handmade in Estelí and recognized for its consistency, the Oliva cigars that we all endear offer pleasure through mind-blowing, bold, and fiery flavors to dance with the palate, but what happens if they were modified to be softer and subtler? Showing their gentler side, the pure Nicaraguan interior, covered with a velvety layer of Ecuador Connecticut wrapper, gives birth to a sweet and elegant cigar named Oliva Connecticut Reserve Toro. The complexion of this cigar is fascinating to behold: golden-honey and buttery tones of blonde. Effortless draw and delicate in flavor, let yourself indulge the extraordinarily smooth nuances of cappuccino, cedarwood, and nice sparkle of spice. So, what are you waiting for? House it in your humidors because we know you’ll be coming back for more.
6 × 50
Wrapper type: Ecuador Connecticut
Length: 6
Ring: 50
Shape: Parejo
Binder: Nicaragua
Filler: Nicaragua
Origin: Nicaragua
Strength: Mellow-Medium
Wrapper Shade: Natural

#6 Gran Habano #1 Connecticut Churchill

If you are looking for economically priced cigar that is of premium quality, opt for the Gran Habano #1 Connecticut Churchill — it was labeled number ‘one’ for a reason. It features a glossy, vibrant green and gold band evoking great familiarity to smokers of this cigar way back 90’s or early 2000s. Placid in nature, it is enveloped in a shimmering, slightly silky Connecticut wrapper veiling finely aged Nicaraguan long-leaf fillers. During the cold draw, your tongue will be embraced by splendid combination of hay, cedar and molasses. As you pamper yourself through the smoke, expect a teasing sweetness from the outset, along with oak and grassy nuances, and a trail of pepper on the creamy finish. Gran Habano #1 Connecticut Churchill is a testament of vintage blending process that never gets old and is perfect to enjoy after a light breakfast.
7 × 48
Wrapper type: Connecticut
Length: 7
Ring: 48
Shape: Parejo
Binder: Nicaraguan Habano
Filler: Nicaraguan Habano
Origin: Honduras
Strength: Mellow-Medium
Wrapper Shade: Natural

#7 Don Diego Corona

#7 Best Mellow Cigar

Don Diego is one of the alluring cigars crafted under the watchful eye of Altadis Corporation — manufacturer of world-renowned brands, such as Montecristo, Por Larrañaga, Romeo y Julieta, and H. Upmann. The excellent quality, fantastic flavors, and relatively cheap price make Don Diego Corona an irresistible entry for deal-seeker aficionados. Everything about this cigar screams elegance — from its enchanting Connecticut shade wrapper, you’ll notice a buttery sheen that is sleek and smooth, sporting few visible veins which conceal a rich Dominican core. It approaches through velvety and mellow smoke, progressing into something earthy with a faint peppery note and spicy nuttiness; also, expect the finish to deliver zero harshness. I definitely recommend you to enjoy this sweet tang of a cigar with mild espresso.
5.50 × 44
Wrapper type: Connecticut Shade
Length: 5.50
Ring: 44
Shape: Parejo
Binder: Dominican Republic
Filler: Dominican Republic / Nicaragua
Origin: Dominican Republic
Strength: Mellow
Wrapper Shade: Natural

#8 Romeo y Julieta Anejados Robusto

#8 Best Mellow Cigar

Romeo y Julieta has built an unblemished reputation embedded in every smoker. Whether it’s a full-bodied or mellow cigar, as long as you allow yourself a stick, be unsurprised of an impeccable smoking experience. If you enjoy the flavor of Honduran tobacco, but in much-restrained strength, then you will love this Romeo y Julieta Anejados Robusto. Beneath the Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper is a Dominican filler held by a blanket of specialized Mexican binder — allowing feathery and succulent nuances to cradle the palate. The finely matured core lends a dominant cedar note during the first third, harmoniously blending with peppermint and unsalted butter. On the second third, the obscured flavors of beechwood, licorice, and earth become evident, and it is then finished by notes of charred oak, star anise, and faint pepper. If you prefer a cigar during a serene sunrise while the birds are chirping, this is the one for you.
5 × 50
Wrapper type: Ecuador Connecticut
Length: 5
Ring: 50
Shape: Parejo
Binder: Mexico
Filler: Nicaragua / Dominican Republic
Origin: Honduras
Strength: Mellow
Wrapper Shade: EMS

#9 Flor de Oliva Gold Torpedo

#9 Best Mellow Cigar

It is an unspoken truth that Oliva needs nothing to prove in the domain of handcrafting tobaccos. Flexible and strategic, Flor de Oliva is home to various fine wrappers to expand your horizons with: the effortlessly soothing and gentle Connecticut shade-grown wrapper, the buttery and silky Corojo wrapper, the flavorsome Maduro wrapper and the sweet and luscious Sumatra wrapper.
Flor de Oliva Gold Torpedo is the right cigar if you’re looking for right: price, construction, and taste. Albeit being mellow-bodied, this Gold Torpedo gives off well-rounded complexity of flavors of nuts, almonds, cedar, and earth. Considering that this is covered in a premium Connecticut wrapper, the 4-dollar price is mystifying. As such, the harmony of price and quality rarely happen— not until you’ve got a taste of Flor de Oliva Gold Torpedo. Who said bundled cigars are second-rate?
6.50 × 52
Wrapper type: Connecticut
Length: 6.50
Ring: 52
Shape: Torpedo
Binder: Nicaragua
Filler: Nicaragua
Origin: Nicaragua
Strength: Mellow
Wrapper Shade: EMS

#10 Rocky Patel The Edge Connecticut Toro

#10 Best Mellow Cigar

The mild, silky, and sweet aromatic Ecuadorian Connecticut shade wrapper complementing the bold Nicaraguan and Honduran filler commands a tamer version of the authentic Rocky Patel The Edge. However, what is never gone is the very same blend that captivates many cigar enthusiasts — only that it’s not daunting to the palates of preferring a milder smoke. The nostalgic flavors of creamy cocoa, cedar, leather, spice, and meringue are assured to bring a blast to everyone who’s tried Rocky Patel The Edge Connecticut Toro, especially when paired with a scotch whisky and sweet red wine.
6 × 52
Wrapper type: Ecuador Connecticut
Length: 6
Ring: 52
Shape: Parejo
Binder: Nicaragua
Filler: Honduras/Nicaragua
Origin: Honduras
Strength: Mellow
Wrapper Shade: Natural