How Cigars are Rated

How Cigars are Rated

Cigar ratings vary depending on how a professional establishes a rating range. The majority use a scale from 1 to 100, with 100 being the highest quality. Others merely give it a simple 1–10 rating.

While the majority of cigars are made by hand and therefore inherently different, they can be rated based on certain factors that generally relate to their construction and flavor.

Cigar ratings vary depending on how a professional establishes a rating range. The majority use a scale from 1 to 100, with 100 being the highest quality. Others merely give it a simple 1–10 rating. Some also rate a cigar’s appearance and its band.

Moreover, cigars are frequently evaluated based on their construction, flavor, aroma, and look. There isn’t, however, a single, unifying system for rating cigars. People differ in their preferences; thus, it is up to each person to determine what elements are most significant to them. But what exactly gets considered when doling out such ratings? We thought it was the right time to shed light on this subject for those who want to learn more about cigars.


One of the first things that are observed about a cigar is the wrapper. It should be free of flaws and can be any color, from light to dark. Given that darker wrappers typically have more full-bodied flavors, they can also provide hints regarding the cigar’s flavor. The color can likewise give you an indication of how the cigar has been aged.

A cigar’s band can also be rated depending on how it looks while being put in a cigar and its design. For the purpose of shielding the cigar from harm, the band is typically constructed of paper or foil. Any creases or gaps should be absent from a decent band, which will be snug and well-fitted.

Most people are particular when it comes to the cigar’s band, especially if it’s from a well-known cigar brand. Bright, vivid colors should be used, and a visually appealing layout should be the goal. Furthermore, the band can provide some insight into the cigar’s quality.


A cigar’s quality can sometimes be in part determined by the way it smells. An enjoyable scent that isn’t overpowering should be present in a decent cigar. An indication of a cigar’s flavor may also be found in its aroma.

The cigar’s aroma is also something that someone can base upon smoking its thirds since aside from it giving them a hint about what flavor it will appear, the strength of its smell is something to be reviewed about.

If you’re looking for a good cigar, make sure to pay attention to its smell. Others do this in order to avoid buying a cigar that is not usually their preference, according to the flavors they can detect.


When rating a cigar, there are numerous things to take into account, but the flavor is probably the most crucial element in figuring out a cigar’s quality. The tobacco used in the cigar’s blend and the aging procedure affect its taste. The cigar’s flavor is also influenced by its wrapper, depending on how light or dark it looks like.

An excellent cigar should have a flavor that is balanced and smooth. The flavor ought to be complex, with various notes discernible as the cigar is smoked. Those who smoke cigars frequently can learn a lot about a cigar just by smelling it. The most excellent way to appreciate a cigar’s flavor, though, is to smoke one.

The flavor of a cigar can significantly affect how much you enjoy it; therefore, it’s crucial to pick one with a flavor you like. You may choose from a wide variety of flavors, so take your time to test out a few different cigars until you find one that you genuinely like.


A cigar’s structure is equally crucial. The roll and draw of a cigar with good construction will be tight and even. Additionally, the cigar should be devoid of any apparent faults.

The outside of the cigar needs to be even and smooth. With no blanks or gaps, the cigar should be completely filled. Additionally, there should be no loose tobacco leaves or unraveling wrappers; the cigar should be tightly made. A cigar with poor construction could be challenging to smoke or taste bad.

The cigar’s size and shape are not totally a requirement in rating a cigar, but it’s essential to take note that flavors also vary based on a cigar’s size and shape. It can also give you an idea of how the cigar will smoke and how long it will last.

Ash and smoke production from a cigar are also addressed in this part. A cigar’s flavor can be impacted by the amount of smoke it produces, and one with too much ash may be challenging to keep lit. A cigar that produces a lot of smoke and has thick, persistent ash is usually well-constructed.

Price Point

Regarding cigars, the price point is unquestionably a factor to be taken into account. It’s critical to comprehend what you’re paying for when buying a cigar because cigar pricing might vary considerably.

It’s worth investing a bit more money if you want a top-notch cigar to smoke because, in general, more expensive cigars tend to be of higher quality, which can result in a more enjoyable smoking experience.

However, there are some great budget options out there as well, so don’t count them out completely. There are instances where a cigar’s high price does not justify its performance or the value of its flavors. But then again, this varies from a person’s cigar preference.

In the end, it’s up to you to choose how much you’re willing to pay for a cigar and how high the cost is to you. Make sure to conduct your research and try a range of cigars before settling on your favorite.

It is ultimately up to the individual to choose which criteria are most significant to them when rating cigars. Some people might focus on the flavor of the cigar, while others might put more emphasis on the cigar’s appearance. There will be a variety of viewpoints, but as long as you appreciate and enjoy the cigar, that is all that matters.